Christmas Movie Rankings

Rank Name Wins Losses Win % Vdiff MF# 1 Christmas Vacation 2 0 100% 6 2.6 2 How the Grinch Stole Christmas 1 0 100% 5 1.5 3 A Christmas Story 1 0 100% 4 1.4 4 Home Alone 1 0 100% 4 1.4 5 Elf 1 1 50% 2 1.2 6 The Polar Express [...]

Christmas Fight 12: Holiday Inn vs. A Christmas Carol (1999)

Christmas Fight 12: Holiday Inn vs. A Christmas Carol (1999) Holiday Inn Current Ranking: 18 PRO BING AND HOLIDAY TRADITIONS: + This movie is the most adorable around. So many of our classic holiday songs are from this movie and the beautiful classic voice of Bing Crosby. You have to admit that when you catch [...]

Christmas Fight 9: How the Grinch Stole Christmas vs. Four Christmases

Christmas Fight 9: How the Grinch Stole Christmas vs. Four Christmases How the Grinch Stole Christmas Current Ranking: 13 PRO FANTASY AND CHRISTMAS SPIRITS: + This movie is spectacular is a suprisingly forgotten Christmas movie so soon after it’s release. Sure it’s a little over the top, but we’ve got the master Jim Carrey, Ron [...]

Christmas Fight 8: White Christmas vs. Christmas Vacation

Christmas Fight 8: White Christmas vs. Christmas Vacation White Christmas Current Ranking: 8 PRO SLICK, SCHMALTZY HOLIDAY CHARMER: + This is an absolute classic. This movie is one of the most underreated, greatest Christmas movies of all time. You have to give this movie the credit that it really deserves. ANTI CHEVY CHASE, THAT BASTARD: [...]

Christmas Fight 7: Eight Crazy Nights vs. I’ll Be Home For Christmas

Christmas Fight 7: Eight Crazy Nights vs. I’ll Be Home for Christmas Eight Crazy Nights Current Ranking: 18 PRO THE SANDMAN’S BEST CHRISTMAS STORY: + This is a brilliant story, depicting how any bah-humbug scrooge’s mentality can be broken and brought back by the Holiday spirit.  It’s funny, cute, well animated, cute songs.  A great [...]

Christmas Fight 6: Home Alone vs. The Nightmare Before Christmas

Christmas Fight 6: Home Alone vs. The Nightmare Before Christmas Home Alone Current Ranking: 4 PRO AHHHHHHHHHHH!: + Macauley Culkin made a career out of this being the greatest Christmas movie of all time. The jokes, the family, the love, everything from top to bottom makes this into one of the greatest films of all [...]

Christmas Fight 5: Love Actually vs. The Santa Clause

Christmas Fight 5: Love Actually vs. The Santa Clause Love Actually Current Ranking: 10 PRO CHARMING BRITISH PEOPLE AND LOVE: + This is by far the most charming movie on this list. If you watch this and don’t cry with joy, Someone should come to your house and steal the diamond that you call a [...]

Christmas Fight 4: Elf vs. It’s a Wonderful Life

Christmas Fight 4: Elf vs. It’s a Wonderful Life Elf Current Ranking: 5 PRO BUDDY AND ZOE: + This is the most adorable Christmas movie of this century. Yeah, I said it. Plus, don’t forget that it is really about Christmas and how great the Christmas spirit is. Oh, and Zoe is adorable too! ANTI [...]

Christmas Fight 3: Jingle All the Way vs. Die Hard 2

Christmas Fight 3: Jingle All the Way vs. Die Hard 2 Jingle All the Way Current Ranking: 28 PRO ARNOLD AND TURBOMAN: + Ok, the main argument for why this is a better (remember) CHRISTMAS movie is that it is about Christmas, gifts, family, love and the father-son bond that only Arnold can fully articulate. [...]

Christmas Fight 2: Bad Santa vs. Scrooged

Christmas Fight 2: Bad Santa vs. Scrooged Bad Santa Current Ranking: 14 PRO NAUGHTY BILLY AND FRIENDS: + This is the raunchiest, funniest, most real world Christmas movie around, but it is also an original concept of the Christmas spirit ANTI 80′S CRAPPY PAP: – Honestly, just because you throw Bill Murray in there doesn’t [...]

Christmas Fight 1 – A Christmas Story vs. Miracle on 34th St

Christmas Fight 1: A Christmas Story vs. Miracle on 34th St (1947) A Christmas Story Current Ranking: 1 PRO RED RIDER: + We can all relate to it. Everyone remembers what life was like as a kid trying desperately to get the one and only present they want. ANTI OLD PSYCHOTIC DUDE: – That movie [...]